Skip to Main Content

Exclusive 10% Discount Applied!

Girl Scout Cookie Swaps

May 28, 2021 | by Cameron Kao
Girl Scout Cookie Swaps


Let’s be real...Girl Scout cookies are some of the best cookies out there. The only downside to them is that they’re sold for a limited amount of time. While you’re waiting for Girl Scout cookie season to come, try out these fun Girl Scout cookie inspired recipes to satisfy your cravings! These recipes are keto-friendly and guaranteed delicious!🍪🍪

1. Toast-yay! 

Are you a fan of the comforting cinnamony, custardy, and vanilla-y flavors packed into Girl Scout toast-yay cookies? Do you love french toast? If so, these keto french toast sticks by Andrea@KetoCoachForWomen are the perfect treats for you to make! Instead of using cinnamon and sugar for coating in this recipe, use 1 package crushed Fat Snax Mini Snickerdoodle Cookies!

2. Thin Mints

Anyone else think that thin mints are the best Girl Scout cookies? Packed with chocolatey and minty flavors, thin mints are both super indulgent and refreshing! If only there was a way to eat them any day, any time you wanted….wait a second there is a way? We came up with a thin mint recipe that you can make at home using only 4 ingredients! 

3. Lemon-Ups

Level up with this Girl Scout lemon-up cookie inspired recipe! Kirbie@KirbieCravings developed this perfectly tart keto lemon mug cake recipe! You know what they say, when life gives you lemons, make lemon mug cake!

4. Lemonades

    Looking for a slightly sweeter lemon recipe? Naomi@NaomiShermanFoodCreative created a deliciously creamy, citrusy, and sweet low-carb lemon meringue parfait recipe! Save time when making this recipe by replacing the crumb base with 1 bag of crushed Fat Snax Soft-Baked Lemony Lemon Cookies!

    5. Trefoils

    Searching for a keto recipe to satisfy your shortbread cookie cravings? Check out our keto Fat Snax crumbled pie crust recipe, which has similar flavor notes as a shortbread cookie crust! Fill up the crust with your favorite filling (such as a keto custard or meringue)! We crust that you can easily make this recipe!

    6. Samoas

    Chocolate, caramel, and coconut might be the most iconic flavor trio ever created. Samoas are known for being the most ooey gooey and sweet Girl Scout cookies. We created our own keto samoa recipe so that you can satisfy your samoa cravings ASAP!

    7. Tagalongs

    Peanut butter and chocolate are both not only delicious, but high in healthy fats and keto-friendly! We keto-fied Girl Scout tagalong cookies to add even more fats to the classic chocolate peanut butter cookies. Fat yeah!

    8. Do-si-dos

    Looking for the perfect snack partner to do-si-do with? Inspired by the classic peanut butter flavors in Girl Scout do-si-do cookies, we came up with a super quick and tasty snack idea! Get out two Fat Snax Soft-Baked Maple Pecan Cookies, spread both with peanut butter, and sandwich them together. Voila, you’ve got yourself a two ingredient do-si-do!

    9. Toffee-tastic

      Calling all toffee-tastic cookie and toffee lovers...did you know that you can make your own toffee easily at home? Carolyn@FoodDreamer created a toffee-tastic low carb cracker toffee recipe! In place of the homemade almond flour crackers in the recipe, use 2 bags of Fat Snax Almond Flour Crackers to subtract 40 minutes from the cook time!

      10. Caramel Chocolate Chip

      Can’t decide if you want cookies or ice cream? Have both! Featuring the classic flavors from Girl Scout caramel chocolate chip cookies, our keto salted caramel ice cream cookie sandwich snack idea is insanely delicious! Place a scoop of your favorite keto salted caramel ice cream between two Fat Snax Soft-Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies and enjoy! You can thank us later.

      11. S'mores

      The only thing that might be better than Girl Scout s’more cookies are actual s’mores. Roast marshmallows over a fire or stove and place them in between Fat Snax Soft-Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies along with some keto chocolate. You’re going to want s’more once you finish your first keto s’more!!

      Make one of these Girl Scout cookie inspired snacks and share it with us @EatFatSnax or 📸

      💚Get your Ingredients!💚